Nchrp project number 1271 transportation research board. The method consists of representing the actual decking system of the bridge by an equivalent grillage of beams. The procedure and recommendations for idealising the actual. Grillage analogy analysis general this analysis approach requires the structure to be modeled as a threedimensional grid of beam elements in which the superstructure is comprised of both longitudinal and transverse beams located at the vertical center of gravity of the superstructure. May 22, 2015 the grillage beam can be in any material, the most usual being either steel, precast concrete or timber. Introduction grillage analogy is probably one of the most popular computeraided analysis for analyzing bridge decks. This document is intended as a design manual for the application of grillage analogy method for the bridge deck analysis. Determining the principal effects of the various loading combinations can often be achieved with a 2dimensional analytical model but for a more comprehensive analysis a 3dimensional model. Grillage model, discretization, impact factor, wearing coat, vehicular live load 1. For the purpose of bridge design, finite element fe analysis and grillage analogy ga have remained as valuable methods. List of studied parameters type of bridge tbeam bridge span 15,20,25,30,35m lane of bridge four lane six lane. Maximum and minimum reactions forces, deflections, bending moments in.
Grillage analysis of bridge decks bridge design bridge. Alternative forms of two lane tbeam bridge superstructure. Grillage analogy in bridge deck analysis civil engineering. The support reactions should then be summed together for that load case. Bridge model ratio plots straight to curve spine and grillage e39 d. Grillage analogy in bridge deck analysis in sap 2000 shz7 structural 28 aug 15 03. Thananjayan added it oct 12, grillate science intl ltd. Pdf analysis of integral abutment bridge by grillage method. This book deals with the well established computeraided method of grillage analogy as applied to analysis of bridge decks. Nov 16, 2015 reliability and accuracy of the grillage analogy ga technique, as a commonly used modelling approach, in structural analyses of bridge decks are evaluated in this research. Apr 03, 2018 bridge deck analysis through the use of grillage models sap 2000.
In some permanent situations, however, where unusual circumstances exist, such as an abundance of durable timber or the possible reuse of existing rolled steel sections, the grillage can prove both successful and economic. Tee beam bridge deck, irc 6, grillage analogy method, skew angle 1. When a bridge deck is analyzed by the method of grillage analogy, there are essentially five steps to be followed for obtaining design responses. Comparative study of grillage method and finite element. Construction of skew bridges results in saving of time and traffic requirements. Grillage analogy in bridge deck analysis free ebook download as pdf file. How to carry out bridge deck grillage analysis using staad. To predict bridge behavior, computer models of the riverside experimental bridge and of the denison field bridge were developed using both. It provides bridge designers with the knowledge to understand the behaviour of bridge decks, to be familiar with, and to understand the various numerical modelling techniques, to know which. The finer grillage mesh, provide more accurate results. Bending moments distribution at the main structural. To predict bridge behavior, computer models of the riverside experimental bridge and of the denison field bridge were developed using both the grillage and finite element methods of analysis. Alternatively, the grillage may be solved by the flexibility or force method, which is usually not applicable to large structures. Grillage analogy applications in analysis of bridge decks request.
Generally, grillage analysis is the most common method used in bridge analysis. For this purpose, the vibration and design parameters including natural frequencies, mode shapes and deflections of the decks are considered as evaluation criteria. Javier rodrigues, francisco martinez, and joaquin marti 20 have been developed a methodology. The method, applicable to various types of bridge decks such as slab bridges, tbeam bridges and boxgirder bridges, can handle rigid or flexible support conditions, and right, skew or curved plan layouts. Skew bridges analysis using grillage analogy vikash khatri et. Grillages are most widely used to analyse beam and slab type bridge decks. Tbeam, bridge, skew angle, finite element, longitudinal moments introduction many methods used in analyzing such as grillage and finite element method. What is grillage foundation, definition, construction, uses. Under ground water tank analysis and designing by staad pro v8i software duration. Aug 23, 2019 grillage analogy in bridge deck analysis by c. Influence of soilstructure interaction on structural behavior of integral bridge piers.
Bridge deck analysis by grillage method is also compared for normal. A complete schedule of parametric study is given in following table. Analysis of skew bridges using computational methods. Grillage analogy in bridge deck analysis in sap 2000 bridge. Y analysis of straight and skewed box girder bridge by finite strip. Aug 09, 2005 the definitive text in the field of bridge deck behaviour and analysis bridge deck analysis is an essential reference for civil and structural engineers. The grillage analogy in bridge analysis researchgate. Based on hambly and surana grillage analogy in bridge deck analysisfor interpretation of cellular deck grillage output, they said the longitudinal moments for true bending design should be average of moments at each side of joints. A suitable grillage mesh for skewed bridges much depends upon the skew angle,thespan length, and the width of the deck. Comparative study of skew slab bridges using grillage. The most common method of analysis is the stiffness or displacement method based on member stiffness. The effect of different skew angles on samespan of reinforced concrete bridges using the finiteelement method and the grillage analogy method is compared.
The idealization of a bridge by a grillage is not axiomatic and is not without pitfalls. Grillage analogy is a probably one of the most popular computer added. Analysis of tbeam bridge deck is done by courbons theory and grillage analogy with the help of staad software. Bridge grillage with advance design america bridge solution part 1 duration. Jul 07, 20 this book deals with the well established computeraided method of grillage analogy as applied to analysis of bridge decks. The grillage beam can be in any material, the most usual being either steel, precast concrete or timber.
The theoretical principles has been expounded in the book of edmund c. A typical example is the grillage analysis of a simply supported bridge deck. Based on hambly and surana grillage analogy in bridge deck analysis for interpretation of cellular deck grillage output, they said the longitudinal moments for true bending design should be average of moments at each side of joints. Pdf bridge deck analysis through the use of grillage. Keogh the definitive text in the field of bridge deck behaviour and analysis bridge deck analysis is an essential reference for civil and structural engineers. Grillage analogy is a popular method for analyzing various types of highway bridges in design offices. Comparative study of grillage analogy and finite element.
Shoja jamali comparative study of grillage analogy and. International journal of latest trends in engineering and technology ijltet vol. Download code bridge deck analysis through grillage models in. Sadeghi and fathali 2012 analyzed concrete deck of a bridge using cdp in grillage analogy ga. To illustrate the grillage analogy in bridge deck analysis, detailed calculations are shown for tbeam bridge for following data. Pdf bridge deck analysis through the use of grillage models. The grillage analogy method for analyzing bridge superstructures has been in use for quite some time. Grillage analogy in bridge deck analysis surana, c. Basically, grillage analogy method uses stiffness approach for analyzing the bridge decks jaggerwal and bajpai, 2014. Surana, 9788173191534, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. The definitive text in the field of bridge deck behaviour and analysis bridge deck analysis is an essential reference for civil and structural engineers.
It provides bridge designers with the knowledge to understand the behaviour of bridge decks, to be familiar with, and to understand the various numerical. Hambly, bridge deck behaviour, chapman and hall, 1976, first edition e. Comparative study of skew slab bridges using grillage analogy. The bridge deck is analyzed by both grillage analogy as well as by finite element method. Reliability and accuracy of the grillage analogy ga technique, as a commonly used modelling approach, in structural analyses of bridge. In this method the deck is represented by an equivalent grillage of beams. The object of the paper is the study of the representativity of the grillage models with which different types of bridge decks are. Introduction generally, grillage analysis 8 is the most common method used in bridge analysis.
Comparative study of rcc skew tbeam bridge using grillage. Bridge deck analysis through grillage models in sap2000. Analysis of composite bridge superstructures using modified. For load assessment of existing bridges in australia, mainly beam line model and grillage analogy are employed to evaluate the structural integrity of bridge components due to live loadings. Reliability and accuracy of the grillage analogy ga technique, as a commonly used modelling approach, in structural analyses of bridge decks are evaluated in this research. Avinash tripathi marked it as toread sep 22, sailaja marked it as toread may 17, their uses are explained through workedout examples. Solid slab type decks are generally modelled using finite elements, however grillages may be used for this type of deck with reasonably accurate results. Analysis of composite bridge superstructures using modified grillage method 944 node. Grillage analogy applications in analysis of bridge decks. In ga, the bridge superstructure is modelled by equivalent longitudinal and transverse beams, while fe analysis discretizes the deck into different. Bridge deck analysis through the use of grillage models sap 2000. Bridge deck analysis by grillage method is also compared for normal meshing, coarse meshing and fine meshing. The majority of highway bridges are beam structures, either single spans or continuous spans, and composite bridges are of either multigirder or ladder deck form. Grillage analogy in bridge deck analysis jlk969d69545.
Grillage modeling approach applied to simplespan slab. Longitudinal grillage members are arranged to represent the main beams with transverse members representing the deck. Bridge deck analysis through the use of grillage models. Bridges, tbeam bridge decks, skew angle, span length, grillage analogy method, grid size class a vehicle. Jan 15, 2001 grillage analogy in bridge deck analysis by c. Longitudinal grillage members are arranged to represent the main beams with transverse members. Request pdf grillage analogy applications in analysis of bridge decks reliability and accuracy of the grillage analogy ga technique, as a commonly used. The visual inspections examined all superstructure elements including the abutments, piers, deck surface, deck soffit, and parapets. Bridge deck analysis through the use of grillage models sap. For a typical load case, the total load applied to the grillage model is known. This bridge with its frpsip deck and its sister bridge with a traditional steelreinforced concrete deck were visually inspected in october 2005, july 2007, and july 2009. First, the theoretical principles on which this kind of modelling is based are recalled. Introduction when stream crosses the road at an angle other than 90. Idealization of physical deck into equivalent grillage evaluation of equivalent elastic inertia of members of grillage application and transfer of loads to various nodes of grillage determination of.
The object of the paper is the study of the representativity of the grillage models with which different types of bridge decks are schematized. In this present study, a solid slab bridge deck studied using grillage and finite element method. Though finite element method gives lesser values for bending moment in deck as compared to grillage analysis, the later method seems to be easy. In ga, the bridge superstructure is modelled by equivalent longitudinal and transverse beams, while fe analysis discretizes the deck into different elements.
497 609 1577 236 701 1233 225 747 375 761 1196 1163 1035 1484 1681 443 755 1545 538 381 426 1607 955 547 333 1118 1310 1662 1190 1664 1378 1038 403 1205 1182 1276 1272 985 62 440 1277 324 171 93